Civil partnerships: new ruling for heterosexual couples

When we talk about civil partnerships, many people assume this applies to a same-sex couple. But this could soon change.

Civil partnerships for heterosexual couplesAfter being denied their right to enter into a civil partnership instead of a marriage, a heterosexual couple have won their appeal to the Supreme Court who unanimously ruled in their favour.

Rebecca Steinfeld and Charles Keidan launched their legal claim around four years ago, during which time they have had two children.

“We are feeling elated,” Rebecca told the BBC. “But at the same time we are feeling frustrated the government has wasted taxpayers’ money in fighting what the judges’ have called a blatant inequality.”

The couple do not believe in the institution of marriage – they consider it to be patriarchal and sexist. They have fought a lengthy legal campaign to open up civil partnerships to heterosexual couples.

The Supreme Court ruling

The highest court in England, the Supreme Court, declared that the ban preventing heterosexual couples from civil partnerships was incompatible with their human rights. In particular, this applied to the right to a private and family life, and amounted to discrimination. This ruling overturns a previous judgment of the Court of Appeal, which rejected the couple’s claim.

This ruling means it is now far more likely that the government will act to change the law.

What is the current law?

Since 2014, the law has provided that heterosexual couples may only marry. Same-sex couples can choose to either marry or enter into a civil partnership. A civil partnership offers legal and financial protection for both parties in the event of relationship breakdown. It is similar to marriage, but free of its religious connotations.

There are already around 63,000 couples in civil partnerships in the UK. There are also 3.3 million unmarried cohabiting couples. Many of these want legal recognition and financial protection. But they cannot get this without entering into marriage.

Other countries already allow couples to choose either a civil partnership or marriage. This would suggest there is a demand for both arrangements. So why isn’t this an option in the UK?

What is the future for civil partnerships?

While the government has acknowledged the inequality between same-sex and heterosexual couples, it is likely that a decision about the future of civil partnerships will take some time to work its way through the legal system.

This would still leave behind the rights of those couples with no formal legal arrangement to recognise their union and who as a result leave their relationships with nothing after many years and who in some instances have had children.

Ultimately, the law needs to catch up with the reality of family life in Britain in 2018.

The Lester Aldridge family team deal with these and other issues on a regular basis and are frequently instructed by clients regarding divorce proceedings.

lester-aldridge-logoIf you would like to discuss any aspect of separation, arrangements for your children or wish to protect your assets prior to getting married, contact the family team on 01202 786161 or email [email protected]

Lester Aldridge LLP

About Lester Aldridge LLP

Lester Aldridge LLP is a nationally recognised law firm with offices in London, Bournemouth and Southampton. The family team are leaders in their field. Jane, Jo and Rosie are specialist family solicitors with a wealth of experience in all areas of family law from divorce to children, prenuptial agreements to the settlement of financial disputes and everything in between. These women are feisty when they need to be. But their approach is designed to reduce conflict in order to ensure the best possible outcome. They recognise that family issues can be extremely emotional and they offer access to specialist advice delivered in a friendly, approachable and understandable way designed to guide you from start to finish. If you would like an informal, no-obligation chat with Jane, Jo or Rosie please telephone 03300 539754.